Advertising effectiveness study
Is Amazon's New Ad Driving You Crazy?
A Hercules survey of 200 young online shoppers in Indian cities found that 65% recall the Amazon brother-and-sister ad, and 54.6% of those who recognised it watch it fully. Wear-out is the risk: 45.5% say it is fine for two or three views, then annoying. Still, 45.5% say it makes them much more positive about Amazon.
Explore the findingsPicked the Amazon sibling ad from a list of four
Of the 130 recognisers, watched without skipping
Say it is fine for 2 to 3 views, then annoying
Based on 200 completed responses. Advertising effectiveness study.
What we set out to answer, and what we found
We tested whether people like the ad and whether repeat viewing wears it out
How far has the ad travelled?
We measured prompted recall of the Amazon brother-and-sister ad against three rival e-commerce ads, and which platforms people remember it on.
Does repetition spoil a liked ad?
We showed the ad, asked for an overall reaction, then asked how many views before it feels tiresome.
Do the creative details hold up?
We tested the Rs 299 tech and Rs 249 fashion price claims, trust in fast delivery, and how natural the sibling banter felt.
What does it do for the brand?
We asked how the ad affects opinion of Amazon, and how likely people are to browse or buy budget electronics and trendy budget apparel there.
Recall is broad. 65.0% picked the Amazon ad from the list, ahead of Flipkart (51.0%), Meesho (44.5%) and Myntra (41.5%). Only 1.5% recalled none of the four.
Most recognisers sit through it. 54.6% watched it fully, 30.0% hit Skip the moment it was available, 10.8% muted it and 4.6% looked away.
Appeal does not stop wear-out. Among the 139 who found the ad very appealing, 40.3% say it is fine for two or three views, then annoying. Across all 200 respondents the figure is 45.5%, the largest group, and 18.0% say even one view is tiring.
The details are believable. 56.0% find the Rs 299 and Rs 249 prices completely believable and 37.0% somewhat. 60.0% call the banter very natural, and 62.0% have high confidence in Amazon's on-time delivery.
The ad helps the brand. 45.5% say it makes them much more positive about Amazon and 44.5% somewhat more. Only 2.5% feel more negative, and 7.5% see no change.
Apparel and electronics move together. 84.0% give trendy budget apparel a top-two score on likelihood to shop, and interest in the two categories correlates at 0.75.
Much More Positive
Say the ad makes them much more positive about Amazon
65% recall the Amazon ad, and Instagram is where 63.8% saw it
We showed four e-commerce ad descriptions and asked which people remember seeing online in the past 30 days. Those who picked the Amazon ad then named the platforms.
Which Video Ads Do You Remember Seeing in the Past 30 Days?
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents. Base: 200
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Amazon: brother and sister arguing about birthday gifts | 65% |
| Flipkart: 'Big Billion Days' teaser | 51% |
| Meesho: everyday household and fashion essentials | 44.5% |
| Myntra: trendy street-style fashion challenge | 41.5% |
| None of these ads | 1.5% |
Platforms Where Recognisers Remember Seeing the Amazon Ad
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents who recalled the ad. Base: 130
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Other platform | 67.7% |
| Instagram (Feed, Stories or Reels) | 63.8% |
| Disney+ Hotstar | 50.8% |
| 44.6% | |
| JioCinema | 39.2% |
| SonyLIV / Zee5 | 30% |
01. Amazon leads Flipkart by 14 points, but no test found a real difference between the two.
02. Instagram and Disney+ Hotstar are close, and the report found no tested difference between them. Both belong in a media plan.
03. Platform and frequency answers are self-reported recall, not logged impressions. The report did not measure unprompted recall.
45.5% tolerate only 2 to 3 views before the ad turns annoying
We asked everyone how many times they could realistically see the ad before it feels tiresome or grating.
How Many Views Before the Ad Feels Tiresome?
Single choice stated threshold, % of respondents. Base: 200
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Fine for 2 to 3 views, then annoying | 45.5% |
| Even 1 time is already tiring | 18% |
| Tolerable up to 5 views | 15% |
| Can watch 6 to 10 times without feeling irritated | 14.5% |
| Fun enough that it wouldn't bother me | 7% |
Tolerance Threshold by How Appealing People Found the Ad
% within each group. Base: 139 found it very appealing and enjoyable, 45 found it somewhat appealing (indicative)
View the data behind this chart
| Very appealing (n=139) | Somewhat appealing (n=45) | |
|---|---|---|
| Fine for 2 to 3 views | 40.3% | 57.8% |
| Even 1 view tiring | 19.4% | 11.1% |
| Up to 5 views | 12.2% | 24.4% |
| 6 to 10 views | 18% | 6.7% |
| Never bothers me | 10.1% | 0% |
01. 63.5% hit their limit at three views or fewer (45.5% plus 18.0%). Only 7.0% say the ad would never bother them.
02. Liking the ad does not protect it. 40.3% of those who found it very appealing still say it turns annoying after two or three views, and 19.4% find a single view tiring.
03. Single-view irritation is 20.4% among women and 15.9% among men, a gap the report did not test.
54.6% of recognisers watch fully, while 30.0% skip at once
We asked people who recognised the ad what they usually did when it popped up.
What Do You Usually Do When the Ad Pops Up?
Single choice, % of respondents who recalled the ad. Base: 130
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Watched it fully without skipping | 54.6% |
| Hit 'Skip Ad' as soon as it was available | 30% |
| Muted the audio and waited for it to finish | 10.8% |
| Switched tab, app or looked away | 4.6% |
01. Watching fully leads skipping at once by about 25 points. Muting and looking away are small.
02. Skipping is the main avoidance behaviour, so the first seconds have to earn attention. The report does not show city differences in avoidance.
03. Only 7.1% of recognised women and 6.8% of recognised men report more than 10 exposures. Those bases are small (56 across both), so the report calls them indicative.
93% find the price claims believable, and 90% find the siblings relatable
We tested the Rs 299 tech and Rs 249 fashion claims, trust in on-time delivery for budget orders, and how the brother-and-sister banter felt.
How Believable Are 'Cool Tech From Rs 299' and 'Trendy Styles From Rs 249'?
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 200
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Completely believable | 56% |
| Somewhat believable, probably only for basic products | 37% |
| Mostly unbelievable, feels like clickbait | 4% |
| Neutral or unsure | 2.5% |
| Completely unbelievable | 0.5% |
How Did the Brother and Sister Banter Feel?
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 200
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Very natural and relatable | 60% |
| Somewhat relatable | 30% |
| Neutral or average | 8% |
| Somewhat staged and unnatural | 2% |
01. Completely believable leads somewhat believable by 19 points. Only 4.0% call the claims mostly unbelievable.
02. Delivery trust is strong: 62.0% have high confidence in Amazon's on-time promise for budget orders and 34.5% moderate. Low confidence is 2.0%.
03. Just 2.0% find the banter staged. The report found 60.0% of Gen Z and 61.0% of young millennials rate it very natural, with no tested age gap.
45.5% feel much more positive about Amazon, and only 2.5% feel more negative
We asked everyone how the ad affects their opinion of Amazon as a shopping destination, then how likely they are to browse or buy in two budget categories.
How Does the Ad Affect Your Opinion of Amazon?
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 200
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Much more positive | 45.5% |
| Somewhat more positive | 44.5% |
| No change | 7.5% |
| Somewhat more negative | 2.5% |
01. 90.0% shift towards Amazon (45.5% plus 44.5%). Brand sentiment has no pre-exposure baseline, so this is a self-rating of the ad's effect, not a measured change.
02. The effect is stronger among fans of the ad: 57.6% of those who found it very appealing feel much more positive, against 17.8% of those who found it somewhat appealing (indicative).
03. 84.0% give trendy budget apparel a top-two score for likelihood to shop. Mean likelihood is 4.32 for budget electronics and 4.25 for apparel. The report could not confirm the scale for electronics and does not rank the two.
04. Interest in the two categories is closely linked, at a correlation of 0.75.
What we would recommend
Practical priorities drawn from this study for further validation.
Cap frequency near the second or third view.
45.5% say the ad is fine for two or three views and annoying after that, and 18.0% find even one view tiring. Waiting for five views would lose most of the audience.
Rotate the creative before wear-out, not after.
Even 40.3% of those who found it very appealing tire after a few views. A liked ad needs a replacement ready.
Keep the price claims and sibling banter in any rework.
93.0% find the prices believable at least somewhat and 90.0% find the banter relatable. These are the strongest parts of the creative.
Make the opening seconds count.
30.0% of recognisers skip at once. A strong first few seconds is the main lever on avoidance, since muting (10.8%) and looking away (4.6%) are small.
Measure the overall irritation rate before pausing the ad.
The study could not give an overall irritation rate, and its tolerance figures are stated, not observed. Track real frequency against drop-off before deciding to pull the ad.