Consumer behaviour study
Why Are We Ditching Cash for Credit?
A Hercules online survey of 5,000 Indian payment-app users found that 84.2% pay by UPI often and 77.7% are comfortable with short-term credit. BNPL use rises from 79.8% to 86.7% across UPI frequency ratings, and 81.1% of BNPL users are comfortable with credit against 57.5% of non-users.
Explore the findingsRate their UPI use 4 or 5 out of 5
Rate comfort with short-term credit 4 or 5
Against 79.8% at the second-lowest rating
Based on 5,000 completed responses. Consumer behaviour study.
What we set out to answer, and what we found
We tested whether frequent UPI use leads people towards digital credit
Does UPI frequency go with BNPL use?
We asked how often people pay by UPI, whether they have used Buy-Now-Pay-Later and which credit products they hold, then compared the three.
Who sits in the active digital base?
We looked at how many people are high-frequency UPI users and whether age or gender changes that.
How comfortable are people with short-term credit?
We asked for a 1 to 5 comfort rating and compared it across age, gender, BNPL use and credit products held.
What the data could not tell us
The survey did not measure market share or overlap across GPay, PhonePe, Paytm and CRED, what people borrow for, or how well they understand fees and interest.
UPI is the default for most of this sample. 84.2% are high-frequency UPI users. The share is close to flat across gender (84.4% of men, 83.6% of women) and runs from 80.3% in the youngest band to 86.7% in the 25 to 32 band.
BNPL use climbs with UPI frequency, modestly. The share who have used BNPL is 86.7% at the top UPI rating and 86.4% at 4, against 79.8% to 80.6% at ratings 1 to 3. The gap is real but about seven points, not a cliff.
Comfort with short-term credit is high. 77.7% rate it 4 or 5. The youngest band is the softest at 73.1%, while the 33+ band is the most comfortable at 80.8%.
BNPL users are the warmest audience. 81.1% of BNPL users are comfortable with short-term credit, against 57.5% of non-users. Among high-frequency UPI users, 95.6% of those who used BNPL hold a credit product, against 69.7% of those who have not.
The survey stops short of app share and fee awareness. It cannot rank GPay, PhonePe, Paytm or CRED, and it did not establish what people borrow for or how well they understand charges.
Comfort: BNPL vs No BNPL
Share comfortable with short-term credit
84.2% pay by UPI often, and age and gender barely move it
We asked how often respondents make UPI transactions on a 1 to 5 scale and treated ratings of 4 and 5 as high frequency.
High-Frequency UPI Users by Age Band
Share rating UPI use 4 or 5, % of each age band. Overall: 84.2% (n=5,000)
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| 25 to 32 | 86.7% |
| 33+ | 86.1% |
| 22 to 24 | 85.7% |
| Youngest band | 80.3% |
High-Frequency UPI Use by Gender
Share rating UPI use 4 or 5, % of each group
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Male | 84.4% |
| Female | 83.6% |
01. 84.2% of the 5,000 respondents are high-frequency UPI users, meaning they gave one of the top two frequency ratings.
02. The youngest band transacts a little less often, at 80.3%, but it is still four in five. The three older bands sit within one point of each other.
03. Men and women are less than one point apart, and the report marks them as similar.
BNPL use rises about 7 points from the lowest to the highest UPI rating
We compared UPI frequency with whether people have used Buy-Now-Pay-Later, and with the credit products they hold.
Have Used BNPL by UPI Frequency Rating
Rating 1 (low) to 5 (high), % of each group. Each bar has its own base
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| 1 | 80.4% |
| 2 | 79.8% |
| 3 | 80.6% |
| 4 | 86.4% |
| 5 | 86.7% |
High-Frequency UPI Users Holding at Least One Credit Product
% of each group. Base: 565 high-frequency UPI users, each bar has its own base
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Have used BNPL | 95.6% |
| Have not used BNPL | 69.7% |
01. BNPL use is flat at 79.8% to 80.6% for ratings 1 to 3, then steps up to 86.4% at rating 4 and 86.7% at rating 5.
02. The correlation between UPI frequency and comfort with short-term credit is 0.70, which the report calls moderate.
03. Among high-frequency UPI users, BNPL users are far more likely to hold a credit product, 95.6% against 69.7%. The report says the non-user group is small, so read that gap as indicative.
04. The report notes the age and city splits show no real gap, so the UPI and BNPL pattern holds across the groups tested.
77.7% are comfortable with short-term credit, but only 57.5% of non-BNPL users
We asked people to rate how comfortable they are using short-term credit, from 1 to 5, and counted ratings of 4 and 5 as comfortable.
Comfortable With Short-Term Credit, by BNPL Use
Share rating 4 or 5, % of each group. Overall: 77.7% (n=5,000)
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Have used BNPL | 81.1% |
| Have not used BNPL | 57.5% |
Comfortable With Short-Term Credit by Age Band
Share rating 4 or 5, % of each age band. Each bar has its own base
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| 33+ | 80.8% |
| 25 to 32 | 80.7% |
| 22 to 24 | 78.8% |
| Youngest band | 73.1% |
01. 77.7% of all 5,000 respondents rate their comfort 4 or 5. Women (78.0%) and men (77.6%) are effectively level.
02. The 23.6-point gap between BNPL users (81.1%) and non-users (57.5%) is the widest of the group splits in the comfort chapter, ahead of age (7.7 points) and gender (0.4 points).
03. Comfort runs from 73.1% in the youngest band to 80.8% among those aged 33 and over. The youngest band is the softest pocket, and its base is large enough to read directly.
04. The city split in this study covers BNPL use only, so comfort by city cannot be read.
People with no credit product are far less likely to give the top comfort rating
We crossed comfort with short-term credit against the credit products respondents hold. Respondents could hold more than one product, so the groups overlap.
Rate Comfort With Short-Term Credit 5 out of 5, by Product Held
% of each group. Base: 7,339 product-holder answers from 5,000 respondents (multiple answers allowed)
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Salary advance (n=1,017) | 44.4% |
| BNPL (n=1,101) | 42.1% |
| Credit card (n=2,679) | 41.6% |
| Personal loan (n=2,119) | 39.7% |
| None (n=423) | 23.4% |
01. The top comfort rating is given by 44.4% of salary-advance holders, 42.1% of BNPL holders, 41.6% of credit card holders and 39.7% of personal loan holders.
02. Among the 423 people holding no credit product, 23.4% give the top rating, and 9.2% give the lowest rating of 1. For credit card, personal loan, BNPL and salary-advance holders, the lowest rating is given by 0.8% to 1.3%.
03. The report says the gap for the no-credit group is untested, so read it as directional.
PhonePe, GPay and Paytm each reach over half the sample, but the survey cannot rank them
The screener asked which payment and finance apps respondents use. People who chose Other were screened out, so these shares describe only users of the listed categories.
Payment and Finance Apps Used
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| PhonePe | 65.4% |
| GPay | 54.8% |
| Paytm | 51.8% |
| CRED | 20.8% |
| Bank app | 17.5% |
01. Because respondents could pick several apps, the shares add to far more than 100%, and the report says the survey does not show market share or user overlap.
02. The questionnaire did not ask what people borrow for, and fee and interest awareness could not be analysed reliably. Those goals are left open.
What we would recommend
Practical priorities drawn from this study for further validation.
Start BNPL cross-selling with frequent UPI users.
84.2% of the sample pay by UPI often, and BNPL use is 86.4% to 86.7% at the top two UPI ratings against 79.8% to 80.6% at the bottom three.
Lead credit offers with people who already hold a product.
81.1% of BNPL users are comfortable with short-term credit against 57.5% of non-users, and holders of cards, loans, BNPL and salary advances give the top rating at 39.7% to 44.4% against 23.4% for those with none.
Test trust messaging on the youngest band first.
Comfort is 73.1% in the youngest band against 80.8% for those aged 33 and over, and their UPI frequency is also the lowest at 80.3%.
Do not split offers by gender.
Men and women are level on UPI frequency (84.4% and 83.6%) and on comfort with credit (77.6% and 78.0%).
Measure app share, borrowing purpose and fee awareness before positioning.
The study could not rank the apps, did not ask what people borrow for, and did not establish how well people understand fees, so those messages are untested.