Consumer behaviour study
Would Gen Z Still Buy Your Brand If Parents Didn't?
A Hercules survey of 1,008 urban Indian Gen Z respondents found that brand trust rests on quality and a record of delivering, not on price or ads. 55.7% have dropped a brand over an ad or post, 96.2% would knowingly buy a dupe somewhere, 68% stay loyal while a brand delivers, and 55.2% would pay more for better quality.
Explore the findingsSay an ad or social post has made them stop using a brand
Would knowingly buy a dupe in at least one category
Somewhat or strongly agree they stay loyal while a brand delivers
Based on 1,008 completed responses. Consumer behaviour study.
What we set out to answer, and what we found
We tested what urban Gen Z trusts, what makes it walk away, and what pulls it towards something new
Does Indian origin win?
We asked which brand people would pick when an Indian and a global brand cost the same, and how far they agree they would rather buy Indian when quality is similar.
How far does dupe culture go?
We asked in which categories respondents would knowingly buy a dupe, and how far they agree that dupes are a smart buy.
Why do people leave a brand?
We asked whether people had stopped using a brand they liked in the last 12 months, their main reason, and whether an ad or social post had ever made them stop.
What earns trust and a premium?
We asked about loyalty, family-trusted brands, creator-started brands, and which drivers would justify paying more.
Indian and global brands are close to level at the same price. 49.4% would pick a global brand and 47.2% an Indian brand when both cost the same. 59% agree they would rather buy Indian when quality is similar, but 23.1% of that is strong agreement.
Dupes are everywhere, but no single category dominates. 96.2% would knowingly buy a dupe in at least one category. Fashion and footwear is highest at 40.4%, and no category reaches half.
Price is a leading exit reason, but not the only one. Of the 678 people who stopped a liked brand, 22.1% found a better alternative and 20.5% said it got too expensive. Quality got worse for 14.7%.
Ads cost brands customers. 55.7% say an ad or social post has made them stop using or buying a brand. As the main reason for a recent breakup it is far smaller, at 8.9%.
Trust is conditional. 68% say they stay loyal only while a brand keeps delivering, and 65% say the brands their family trusted are still the ones they trust.
Quality is the premium lever. 55.2% would pay more for better quality, ahead of brand reputation (41.7%) and a longer warranty (38.1%).
Pay More for Quality
Name better quality as a reason to pay more, the top driver
At the same price, 49.4% pick a global brand and 47.2% an Indian one
We asked which brand people would choose if an Indian and a global brand were priced the same, and how far they agree they would rather buy Indian when quality is similar.
Indian vs Global Brand at the Same Price
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 1,008
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| A global brand | 49.4% |
| An Indian brand | 47.2% |
| No preference | 3.4% |
Agreement: "When quality is similar, I would rather buy an Indian brand"
% of respondents. Base: 1,008
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Strongly agree | 23.1% |
| Somewhat agree | 35.7% |
| Neither | 20.6% |
| Somewhat disagree | 12.2% |
| Strongly disagree | 8.4% |
01. The 2.2-point gap between global (49.4%) and Indian (47.2%) is not tested in the report, so neither origin can be called the winner.
02. 59% agree strongly or somewhat that they would rather buy Indian at similar quality. The report calls that a mild lean, not a strong pull, with 23.1% strongly agreeing.
03. Unprompted recall points the same way: 35% of respondents named an Indian brand and 33% a global brand, with 23% naming both.
96.2% would buy a dupe somewhere, yet no category reaches half
We asked every respondent in which categories they would knowingly buy a dupe. They could pick several.
Categories Where Respondents Would Knowingly Buy a Dupe
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents. Base: 1,008
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Fashion and footwear | 40.4% |
| Smartphones | 36.9% |
| Watches, bags and accessories | 35.4% |
| Online shopping or quick-commerce apps | 35.3% |
| Entertainment apps | 32.6% |
| Home and lifestyle | 31.4% |
| Packaged snacks and beverages | 26.7% |
| Beauty and grooming | 26.4% |
| Payment or fintech apps | 25.5% |
| Cafes and quick-service restaurants | 22.9% |
| None: would not knowingly buy a dupe | 3.8% |
01. Only 3.8% say they would not knowingly buy a dupe anywhere, which is where the 96.2% comes from.
02. Fashion and footwear leads at 40.4%, followed by smartphones (36.9%) and watches, bags and accessories (35.4%). Cafes and quick-service restaurants are lowest at 22.9%.
03. Agreement that dupes are a smart buy is lukewarm. 30.9% somewhat agree and only 10.7% strongly agree, while 20.2% somewhat disagree and 11.1% strongly disagree.
04. The report finds similar dupe appetite in both age bands, 97.5% for 18-24 and 93.8% for 24-35, and does not test the gap.
Of 678 people who dropped a brand, 22.1% found a better one and 20.5% found it too expensive
We asked whether respondents had stopped using or buying a brand they liked in the last 12 months. Those who had gave their main reason.
Main Reason for Stopping a Brand They Used to Like
% of respondents who stopped a liked brand. Base: 678
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Found a better alternative | 22.1% |
| Too expensive | 20.5% |
| Quality got worse | 14.7% |
| Stopped feeling relevant to me | 12.4% |
| Did not fit my lifestyle or values | 11.1% |
| Poor service or delivery | 10% |
| An ad or social media post put me off | 8.9% |
| Others | 0.3% |
01. 678 of 1,008 respondents, or 67.3%, stopped using a brand they liked in the past year.
02. Price is level with the top reason, not far above the rest. The report tests that price stays at about 21% whether or not an ad drove the exit.
03. Among the brands people named, 40% of coded answers were electronics or smartphone brands, 24 points ahead of fashion. The report also lists Nike, Xiaomi, Coca-Cola and Paytm among individual names.
55.7% say an ad or post has made them drop a brand, but only 8.9% name it as the main reason
We asked everyone whether an ad or social post had ever made them stop using or buying a brand, and asked them to tell us what happened.
Ad-Driven Exits: Ever vs Main Reason
% of each group. Different bases, so read each bar against its own group
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Ever dropped a brand over an ad or post (all respondents, n=1,008) | 55.7% |
| Ever dropped a brand over an ad or post (among those who stopped a liked brand, n=678) | 71.5% |
| Ad or post is the main reason for the recent breakup (n=678) | 8.9% |
What Happened: Coded Stories of Brand Exits
Coded themes, multiple answers allowed. Base: 550 coded respondents
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Unclear or miscellaneous answers | 37.3% |
| Ad or social post triggered exit | 20.2% |
| Product quality or authenticity failure | 20% |
| Positive experience or trust retained | 10.2% |
01. The 55.7% is a lifetime measure of whether an ad ever pushed someone away. As the stated main reason for a recent breakup it is 8.9%, so ads rarely act alone.
02. Among people who say an ad drove an exit, 60% work full-time against 54% of those who do not. 38% say parents or family mostly pay for their purchases, against 23% of others. The report does not test these gaps.
03. Ad-exit rates are similar across the two age bands: 58% in the younger band and 52% in the older band, an untested gap.
04. The stories behind ad exits cite hyped launches and fake product claims. Ad-triggered stories (20.2%) sit level with product quality failures (20.0%).
“A body wash named chemist at play was so hyped and wanted to buy but seeing genuine reviews not buy” Respondent, ad or social post triggered exit
“It was posted on Instagram about Fake Nike shoes how they make in Factory of Agra sold as original” Respondent, ad or social post triggered exit
“My order was delayed twice and customer support did not help so I stopped using it” Respondent, poor service, delivery or app issues
68% stay loyal only while a brand delivers, and 65% still trust what their family trusted
We asked how far respondents agree with a battery of attitude statements. Two of them covered loyalty and inherited trust.
Agreement With Two Brand-Trust Statements
% of respondents. Base: 1,008
View the data behind this chart
| I stay loyal to a brand as long as it keeps delivering | The brands my family trusted are still the ones I trust | |
|---|---|---|
| Strongly agree | 33.7% | 28.5% |
| Somewhat agree | 34.4% | 36.8% |
| Neither | 19.5% | 19.9% |
| Somewhat disagree | 7.7% | 9.3% |
| Strongly disagree | 4.7% | 5.5% |
01. Loyalty is conditional. 68% somewhat or strongly agree they stay only as long as the brand delivers, the strongest headline for loyalty in the study.
02. Inherited trust holds up. 65% agree that the brands their family trusted are still the ones they trust, and the report finds no difference by age or by current situation.
03. On average, 29% of the brands each respondent knows were started because a family member used them. Across all brand links, 29% were chosen and 23% inherited, 25% were never used and 24% lapsed. The report does not test inherited against chosen.
04. 31% rate creator-started brands as more trusted than other brands, and only 2% have not heard of any creator-started brand.
Samsung is known by 62% and used by 36%, while Google Pixel and Nothing lag on use
We asked which smartphone brands respondents had heard of, and which they had used in the last three months.
Smartphone Brands: Aware vs Used in Last 3 Months
% of respondents. Awareness base: 1,008. Use base: 963
View the data behind this chart
| Aware | Used in last 3 months | |
|---|---|---|
| Samsung | 62% | 36% |
| Apple | 57% | 28% |
| Google Pixel | 44% | 11% |
| Nothing | 39% | 8% |
01. Samsung is known by 62% and used by 36%. Apple is known by 57% and used by 28%.
02. Google Pixel is known by 44% but used by 11%. Nothing is known by 39% and used by 8%.
03. When asked which brand they rely on most when it matters, 24% name Samsung and 20% name Apple. The report notes that gap is untested.
04. Only 2% say they rely on no brand in particular, so trust is anchored to a named brand for almost everyone.
What we would recommend
Practical priorities drawn from this study for further validation.
Lead premium messaging with quality, and give it proof.
55.2% would pay more for better quality, ahead of reputation (41.7%) and warranty (38.1%). Back the claim with a warranty or a visible track record.
Test ad tone before launch.
55.7% say an ad or post has made them stop using a brand. Check campaigns for claims that could read as hype, and pair any creator push with proof of quality.
Answer the "better alternative" reason before cutting price.
Better alternative (22.1%) edges out too expensive (20.5%) as the main reason people leave. A discount alone does not address why someone switched.
Treat Indian origin as a supporting message.
Preference at equal price is split 49.4% global to 47.2% Indian, and Made in India ranks fourth as a premium driver. The report has no category split yet.
Use family trust as a route in, then keep delivering.
65% still trust what their family trusted, but 68% stay loyal only while a brand delivers. Heritage opens the door and delivery keeps it open.