Consumer behaviour study
India's Mobile Network Switch
A Hercules online survey of 5,000 Indian mobile users found that 76.8% are considering a network switch within three months. 90.4% are on prepaid and 69.3% spend in the middle band. Switching intent runs from 72.7% among Jio users to 82.4% among Airtel users, and no operator is tested as higher.
Explore the findings3,840 of 5,000 within the next three months
4,521 of 5,000, against 9.6% on postpaid
Spend 200 to 400 a month
Based on 5,000 completed responses. Consumer behaviour study.
What we set out to answer, and what we found
We measured how many mobile users are open to leaving, and who they are
Who holds the primary connection?
We asked which network each respondent uses as their primary connection, and how that splits by age, gender and city.
How is the base built?
We measured the prepaid and postpaid mix and the monthly mobile spend band of each respondent.
How much churn exposure is there?
We asked whether each respondent is considering switching networks within the next three months.
Where does the risk sit?
We compared switching consideration by current network, spend band, payment type, age, gender and city.
Most users are open to leaving. 3,840 of 5,000 respondents (76.8%) say they are considering a network switch within the next three months. This is intent, not completed ports.
Risk is spread across every operator. Switching consideration is 82.4% among Airtel users, 78.4% for BSNL, 74.6% for Vi and 72.7% for Jio. The report finds no operator tested as higher than the rest.
The base is overwhelmingly prepaid. 90.4% are on prepaid and 9.6% on postpaid. Postpaid share is higher among BSNL users than Jio users, and higher in the youngest age band.
One spend band carries the volume. 69.3% spend in the 200 to 400 band, against 15.8% in 400 to 700, 8.2% under 200 and 6.7% at 700 or above.
Lower spend means more intent, but not by a tested margin. 83.4% of the lowest band are considering a switch, against 72.7% of the top band. The bands are not tested against each other.
Jio and Airtel users fill the switcher pool. 46.3% of potential switchers are on Jio and 41.0% on Airtel today, a reflection of their size in the base.
Highest Switching Intent
Among Airtel users, the top network figure
76.8% are considering a switch within three months, and every network is exposed
We asked everyone whether they are considering switching mobile networks in the next three months, then compared the answer by current primary network.
Considering a Switch Within Three Months, by Current Network
% of each network's users. Overall: 76.8% (3,840 of 5,000)
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Airtel users | 82.4% |
| BSNL users | 78.4% |
| Vi users | 74.6% |
| Jio users | 72.7% |
01. 3,840 of 5,000 respondents are considering a switch. That makes the group open to a move larger than the group that is not.
02. The spread from Jio (72.7%) to Airtel (82.4%) is 9.7 points, but the report says the gap is untested, so Airtel is a lead to check, not a confirmed risk. BSNL rests on a small group.
03. By payment type, 77.1% of prepaid users and 74.3% of postpaid users are considering a switch. These two figures are not tested against each other.
04. The survey did not measure how many switchers are still undecided about where to go, or which network they favour.
90.4% of users are on prepaid, 9.6 times the postpaid share
We asked whether each connection is prepaid or postpaid. The split is tested and not a chance result.
Prepaid or Postpaid?
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 5,000. Postpaid is 479 of 5,000
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Prepaid (4,521 of 5,000) | 90.4% |
| Postpaid (479 of 5,000) | 9.6% |
01. The report puts prepaid at 9.4 times the postpaid share, an 81-point lead that passed its significance test.
02. Postpaid share is significantly higher among BSNL users than among Jio users, and higher in the youngest age band.
03. Postpaid is a small group, so its switching figure of 74.3% should be read as indicative.
69.3% spend in the 200 to 400 band, and only 6.7% spend 700 or more
We asked every respondent how much they spend on mobile each month, using four bands.
Monthly Mobile Spend
% of respondents, in rupees per month. Base: 5,000
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Under 200 | 8.2% |
| 200 to 400 | 69.3% |
| 400 to 700 | 15.8% |
| 700 or more | 6.7% |
01. 3,464 of 5,000 respondents sit in the 200 to 400 band. The 400 to 700 band holds 15.8%.
02. The middle band is the largest share in every age group the report checked, so the pattern is not an age effect.
03. High-value spenders are a small group. The 700-plus band is 6.7% of the base.
Lowest spenders show the most switching intent at 83.4%, the top band the least at 72.7%
We compared switching consideration across the four monthly spend bands.
Considering a Switch, by Monthly Spend Band
% of each band, in rupees per month
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Under 200 | 83.4% |
| 400 to 700 | 80.8% |
| 200 to 400 | 75.5% |
| 700 or more | 72.7% |
01. Intent is high in all four bands, from 72.7% to 83.4%. The report says the bands are untested against each other and cannot be ranked.
02. The pattern does not follow spend in a straight line: the 400 to 700 band (80.8%) sits above the 200 to 400 band (75.5%).
03. The report suggests testing retention offers on the lowest-spend group first, since its figure is the highest.
Jio and Airtel users make up 87.3% of the people considering a switch
We looked at the current primary network of the 3,840 respondents considering a switch.
Current Primary Network of Potential Switchers
% of potential switchers. Base: 3,840
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Jio | 46.3% |
| Airtel | 41% |
| Vi | 8.6% |
| BSNL | 4% |
| Other | 0.1% |
Primary Network Across All Respondents
% of respondents
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Jio | 48.9% |
| Airtel | 38.3% |
| Vi | 8.9% |
| BSNL | 3.9% |
01. 46.3% of potential switchers are on Jio and 41.0% on Airtel, which adds to 87.3%. Vi accounts for 8.6% and BSNL for 4.0%.
02. These are shares of the switchers, not of each operator's users, and they track the operators' weight in the whole sample (48.9% Jio, 38.3% Airtel).
03. The survey did not show which networks switchers are moving to, so the data cannot name an acquisition target.
Switching intent sits between 74.0% and 80.3% in every age band
We compared switching consideration across age, gender and city.
Considering a Switch, by Age Band
% of each age band. Labels as printed in the report
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| 32+ | 80.3% |
| 6-21 | 76.3% |
| 25-31 | 76% |
| 22-24 | 74% |
01. The 32+ band reads 80.3% and the 22-24 band 74.0%. No gap between age bands is tested as real.
02. Women show 81.0% considering a switch and men 75.3%, on a base of 1,277. The gap is untested. The sample is 74.5% male.
03. City figures range from 71% in Mumbai to 86.1% in Jaipur and 86.0% in Varanasi. Several city bases are small and the report marks them indicative, so use them to plan tests, not set targets.
What we would recommend
Practical priorities drawn from this study for further validation.
Start retention on the prepaid base now.
90.4% of users are prepaid and 77.1% of prepaid users are considering a switch. Offers that work on prepaid reach almost the entire market.
Spread retention across Jio and Airtel, and test an Airtel offer first.
87.3% of potential switchers are on Jio or Airtel, and Airtel users show the top figure at 82.4%. The gap to Jio (72.7%) is untested, so start with a small test offer on the Airtel base before moving budget.
Add a destination question before building acquisition offers.
The survey shows where switchers are now, not where they plan to go. Ask which network each switcher favours before naming an acquisition target.
Test spend-specific offers rather than assuming a safe band.
83.4% of the lowest band and 72.7% of the top band are considering a switch. Both figures are high, and the bands are untested against each other, so test before scaling.
Do not read intent as churn.
A 76.8% consideration rate measures openness over three months. Treat it as an upper bound on churn exposure and validate against actual port-out data.