Consumer behaviour study
Is Your Music App Worth the Upgrade?
A Hercules survey of 1,798 active music streamers in India found that ads, not audio quality, are the loudest complaint. 37.9% of coded respondents named free-tier advertising as their most frustrating thing, ahead of subscription cost at 15.2%. Spotify leads recent use at 54.8%, and 49.9% treat music as background noise.
Explore the findingsPast 3 months, among all respondents
Of coded answers name free-tier advertising (n=1,720)
Casual fans, music is background noise for commute and tasks
Based on 1,798 completed responses. Consumer behaviour study.
What we set out to answer, and what we found
We asked what keeps listeners on free and what might make them pay
Does audio quality sell premium?
We set out to test whether lossless, spatial and Dolby Atmos audio drive premium sign-ups and retention. The data could not show this, and the report says so.
Which apps lead?
We asked which music apps people used in the past three months, which they know, and which one is their primary app.
When do people stream?
We asked in which moments of the day people stream music most often, and how they describe their relationship with music.
What frustrates listeners most?
We asked for the single most frustrating thing about their current primary app, and coded the open answers into themes.
Spotify leads reach. 54.8% used Spotify in the past three months, against 43.8% for YouTube Music, 36.7% for JioSaavn and 29.3% for Amazon Prime Music. Spotify has the strongest recall too, but the data does not show why.
Ads are the loudest complaint. 37.9% of coded answers name advertising in the free tier as the single most frustrating thing, 23 points ahead of subscription cost and paywalls at 15.2%.
Audio quality is rarely the complaint or the brand link. Only 2.4% name audio quality shortfalls as their top frustration, and few people link any brand with sound quality.
Most listeners are casual. 49.9% say music is background noise for their commute and tasks, 27.0% call themselves audiophiles, 20.1% are discovery enthusiasts and 3.0% are social sharers.
Bedtime is the biggest moment. 42.3% stream most often before sleep, ahead of working or studying and exercising at 37.4% each.
The core audio question is open. The data does not show whether lossless, spatial or Dolby Atmos audio drives premium sign-ups, and it holds no ranking of playlists, sharing, UI smoothness or offline mode.
Stream Before Sleep
The most common streaming moment
Spotify leads recent use at 54.8%, 11 points ahead of YouTube Music
We asked which music streaming apps people had actively used in the past three months.
Apps Actively Used in the Past 3 Months
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents. Base: 1,798
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Spotify | 54.8% |
| YouTube Music | 43.8% |
| JioSaavn | 36.7% |
| Amazon Prime Music | 29.3% |
| Gaana | 28.1% |
| Apple Music | 23.4% |
| Wynk Music | 22% |
01. Spotify leads YouTube Music by 11 points, and the report finds the lead tested and real. 985 of 1,798 respondents used it.
02. Among respondents who know Spotify (n=1,036), 77.2% used it in the past three months, so awareness mostly converts to use.
03. Spotify is the primary app for 34.9% of qualified respondents asked (n=627). Apple Music is at 23.4% recent use, behind Gaana and Amazon Prime Music.
04. When asked which brands come to mind first, Spotify is top of mind, and sound quality is rarely named as a brand association.
Ads in the free tier are the top frustration at 37.9%, 23 points above cost
We asked for the single most frustrating thing about their current primary music streaming app, and coded the open answers into themes.
Most Frustrating Thing About Primary Music App
Coded open answers, % of coded respondents. Base: 1,720
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Advertising in the free tier | 37.9% |
| Unclear or non-answers | 25.3% |
| Subscription cost and paywalls | 15.2% |
| Repetitive or poor recommendations and controls | 12.8% |
| Lag, slow loading, cluttered interface | 10.6% |
| Missing songs and licensing gaps | 3.4% |
| Audio quality shortfalls | 2.4% |
01. Ads reach 37.9% against 15.2% for subscription cost, a gap of 23 points. Recommendations and controls follow at 12.8% and interface lag at 10.6%.
02. Audio quality shortfalls are the smallest named theme at 2.4%, which is hard to square with a high-fidelity upsell as the first lever.
03. Several answers link ads and weak recommendations in the same sentence, and the report treats the frustrations as what annoys users, not a ranking of what they want.
“Too many ads in the free version.” Respondent, coded as Advertising in the free tier
“Ads between songs” Respondent, coded as Advertising in the free tier
“High subscription fee” Respondent, coded as Subscription cost and paywalls
“The recommendation algorithm keeps looping the same few songs instead of discovering new music.” Respondent, coded as Repetitive or poor recommendations and controls
49.9% treat music as background noise, and only 27.0% are audiophiles
We asked everyone which statement best describes their relationship with music.
Which Statement Best Describes Your Relationship With Music?
Single choice, % of respondents. Base: 1,798
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Casual fan: music is background noise | 49.9% |
| Audiophile: obsessed with sound quality | 27% |
| Discovery enthusiast: love finding new indie music | 20.1% |
| Social sharer: love sharing music with friends | 3% |
01. Casual fans lead audiophiles by 23 points. Together the two largest groups cover 77% of respondents.
02. Discovery enthusiasts are 20.1% and social sharers only 3.0%.
03. The audiophile group, at 27.0%, is the natural audience for lossless audio, but the report could not size how many would pay for it.
42.3% stream music most often before sleep, the top moment
We asked in which situations or daily moments people stream music most often.
Situations When Respondents Stream Music Most Often
Multiple answers allowed, % of respondents. Base: 1,798
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| Relaxing or before sleep | 42.3% |
| Working or studying | 37.4% |
| Exercising or workouts | 37.4% |
| Doing household chores | 36.4% |
| Social gatherings or parties | 33.6% |
| Commuting or driving | 33.4% |
Streaming Time Per Week
% of respondents. Base: 1,798
View the data behind this chart
| Answer | Share |
|---|---|
| 1 to 4 hours | 63% |
| 5 to 10 hours | 28.9% |
| 11 to 20 hours | 5.2% |
| More than 20 hours | 2.9% |
01. The before-sleep lead over working or studying is 5 points, and the report marks it as significant.
02. The other five moments sit within 4 points of each other, between 33.4% and 37.4%, so streaming is spread across the day.
03. Streaming time is modest. 63.0% stream 1 to 4 hours a week, 28.9% for 5 to 10 hours, 5.2% for 11 to 20 hours and 2.9% for more than 20 hours.
Most coded spend answers sit at Rs 101 to Rs 999 a month
We also asked how much people spend out of pocket on music streaming each month, and what upgrade would make them switch their primary app.
01. 52.5% of coded answers about monthly out-of-pocket spend mention a moderate spend of Rs 101 to Rs 999. This is a coded multi-answer question, so shares can exceed 100% across themes.
02. When asked what upgrade would make them switch their primary app, 39.7% of coded answers were unclear, brand-only or miscellaneous.
What we would recommend
Practical priorities drawn from this study for further validation.
Lead premium messaging with an ad-free promise.
Ads are the top frustration at 37.9%, 23 points ahead of subscription cost. Target free listeners with a clear ad-relief offer, and test a lighter ad load before selling higher fidelity.
Test willingness to pay for lossless before building a tier.
Only 2.4% name audio quality as their top frustration, and the study could not show whether lossless, spatial or Dolby Atmos sells. Run a separate price test with the 27.0% who call themselves audiophiles.
Keep features simple for background listeners.
49.9% treat music as background noise, so bets on complex features should be tested, not assumed.
Fix recommendations alongside ads.
Repetitive or poor recommendations and controls are the third named theme at 12.8%, and several respondents tied them to ads in the same answer.
Build relaxing, bedtime experiences.
42.3% stream most often before sleep, the biggest single moment. Playlists and features for winding down fit a clear need.